Saturday, January 16, 2016

In charity circles, even good statistics may be bad

This post came out from The Business Times (30 May 2014)

Imagine that you're running a charity. Suppose you have evidence showing that your charity is highly effective - that you are really making a difference in people's lives. In your fundraising campaign, should you emphasise how effective you are?

In a new study, Yale University economist Dean Karlan and Clemson University economist Daniel Wood offer a surprising answer. It turns out that large donors respond positively to statistical evidence of effectiveness - but small donors respond negatively. There's a major lesson here for the charitable sector, and the lesson has implications for other activities and institutions, including political campaigns, health education and various businesses.

Many people give emotionally, and almost automatically. For some of us, giving produces a kind of warm glow, and we give in part because we want to enjoy that glow. To warm-glow givers, numbers don't much matter. If a charity wants to reach them, it would probably do best to provide photographs or a moving narrative about a needy child or family.

Other people give money because of their judgement that, all things considered, certain charities will significantly help people. Donors of this kind are willing to do at least a little calculating. They won't necessarily do a lot of homework, but they care a lot about whether their money is being put to good use.

This distinction between the two kinds of givers corresponds to the psychologists' distinction, elaborated at length by Nobel Prize winner Daniel Kahneman, between two ways of thinking: fast and slow. Fast thinking is intuitive and emotional. When people are thinking fast, visual images are important. Slow thinking is more deliberate. When people are thinking slowly, numbers count.

Dr Karlan and Dr Wood contend that large donors are more likely to be slow thinkers, focusing on the actual effects of their donations, whereas small donors are faster thinkers and more likely to be reacting emotionally. The researchers know that this is not the only possible explanation of their finding; for example, large donors might be more educated and therefore more likely to focus on statistical evidence of a positive impact. But their preferred explanation is consistent with a growing body of evidence that when potential donors are presented with statistics and numbers - for example, how many people might be saved or are at risk - their willingness to give tends to decrease.

In recent years, many people have been trying to evaluate the real-world effectiveness of various charities. These evaluations are important, but if a charity wants to attract small donors, it might be a mistake to highlight them,. For charities, as for institutions of many different kinds, the central lesson is clear: Statistical information might have a major impact on some people, but to others, it might be irrelevant - or even counterproductive.

Thoughts:

  1. I believe that there are a number of needy Singaporeans who are either not aware of the help available or do not wish to seek help for what so ever reasons.
  2. For those who are not aware of help, the challenge is for the Government to make the information on social assistance available to them, but yet not portraying a state of social welfare-ism.

Thoughts anyone?

Yours,
Something Small Thinking Big

Wednesday, January 13, 2016

The need for better informed donors

This post came out from Today (30 May 2014)

Over the past decade, we have seen an increase in donors who seek more information on the finances of charities, so they can make better informed decisions on contributions. The National Volunteer and Philanthropy Centre's (NVPC) Individual Giving Survey 2012 revealed that people who agreed that "non profits use donated funds properly" gave, on average, a whopping 58 per cent more than those who disagreed.

The Government has been helping charities improve their transparency and governance through training courses and board assessment and providing services to match potential board members to charities. These are further signs of a giving public wanting to be better informed, which is an important foundation in ensuring philanthropic resources are used in a transparent manner, and are well engaged and well utilised.

If donors are making decisions to give primarily based on how much a charity allocates to its beneficiaries, what will be the effect on other needs critical to a charity's operations? Logic tells us it is impossible for a charity to allocate all its funds to direct beneficiary expenses and ignore the realities of operating overheads, salaries, training and development, as well as governance costs.

There has been recent media attention on a more utilitarian view of philanthropy, which focuses on the "bang for the buck". This has inspired some donors to look for the greatest benefit that can be created from the amount they give. Charities with funding needs that are harder to translate into direct benefit may appear less attractive to these donors.

It may also mean donors making giving decisions relatively, based on their understanding of expected benefits. For example, if donors expect less social benefit from funding staff training, compared with the expected benefit of providing food packs to the hungry, they will donate less to the staff training programme and more to the food pack programme.

There can possibly be a different outcome if there is a shift in perspective among donors. For instance, instead of how much of what they give goes to the beneficiaries, donors can ask how their donations can help a charity and the beneficiaries it serves.

The latter question looks not literally at how the money is spent, but how the spending has improved the charity's ability to make a difference to the people it serves. For example, it may have helped pay for another social worker to increase outreach to underserved areas. Or, perhaps, it will improve facilities, so beneficiaries have a better quality of service or fund research and innovation for new solutions to entrenched problems.

Donors who see the bigger picture of helping selected charities are not any less informed about how these organisations operate and whether intended results have been achieved. Besides a charity's annual reports, governance filings and print and social media, there are many resources to help an informed donor. Additionally, volunteering is a very effective way to better understand the impact of the charity's work on the ground.

Every donor wants his donation to count, so transparency, active communication and sensible financial planning on the part of a charity is crucial. Yet, informed givers should go beyond a narrow focus on accountability to look at how their donations can bring greater social benefit. Imagine how much more effective and powerful the non-profit sector can be in addressing social issues if it has the support of an informed giving community.

Thoughts:
  1. I admit being one of those that looks at how the money that I have donated will better help the beneficiary. Another side of the coin to support my argument - If the charity does not have funds to employ people, maintain venues to provide service, how sure are we that the money we donated (to help the beneficiary) will be put into good use? Thus, transparency is very important, and explanation of how the donated fund will be used would put a donor's mind at ease.
Thoughts anyone?

Yours,
Something Small Thinking Big

Sunday, January 10, 2016

What each document covers - These forms aim to ensure that your wishes on how to live out your final days are fulfilled

This post came out from The New Paper (10 July 2014)

Advance Care Planning
Made by: Anyone, regardless of age or health
What it is: Enables people to know what your treatment preferences are in a medical crisis, if you cannot speak for yourself. This empowers them to make decisions for you, although it is not a legal document and can be revoked verbally.
Who it involves: Your substitute decision makers, and an ACP facilitator, who is usually a doctor, nurse or medical social worker.

Advance Medical Directive
Made by: Any person aged 21 years and above who is not suffering from a mental disorder.
What it is: A legal document which you sign in advance to inform your doctor that you do not want any life-sustaining treatment used to prolong your life in the event you are terminally ill and unconscious, where death is imminent.
Who it involves: It is activated only when a panel of three doctors certifies that you are terminally ill. It does not have to involve your loved ones, who may not fully understand the reasons for your decision.

Lasting Power of Attorney
Made by: A person who is 21 years old and above
What it is: The appointment of one or more persons, called a donee, to act and make decisions on your behalf should you lose your mental capacity.
Who it involves: Donees are empowered to act in two areas: personal welfare, as well as property and financial affairs. It does not give them the authority to make life-sustaining treatment decisions on your behalf.

Thoughts:
  1. Have you start planning yet? Good to know more about these! It can alleviate any stressors that your caregiver might experience too.  
Thoughts anyone?

Yours,
Something Small Thinking Big

Saturday, January 9, 2016

Fall in cases lodged over maintenance of parents

This post came out from The Straits Times (26 November 2015)

The number of elderly people in Singapore may be rising, but the number forced to seek state intervention to obtain financial support from their children is down. There were 213 cases lodged with the Commissioner for the Maintenance of Parents last year, a fall from 257 in 2013 and 303 in 2012. The number of people aged above 65 now makes up 11.2 per cent of the population.

The Maintenance of Parents Act was passed in 1995 so the state can intervene and possibly order children to provide financial maintenance when elderly Singaporeans cannot support themselves but their children are not helping.

Grown up children still remain a key source of physical, emotional, and financial support for the elderly, the Ministry of Social and Family Development (MSF) said in its latest report on Ageing Families in Singapore released yesterday.

The report is based on data from various sources such as those in a 2013 HDB Sample Household Survey, which found that 75 per cent of younger married residents provided regular financial support to their parents.

Likewise, 78 per cent of elderly residents with children reported receiving such financial support. On average, an elderly parent received $535 a month from his children in 2013. At least 77 per cent of elderly residents also said they were able to rely on their children for emotional and physical support, such as buying groceries, transportation and housework.

For elderly residents unable to rely on families for such help, the state has developed home care services, providing food, nursing, therapy, transport and cleaning. A new home care centre managed by Touch Community Services was officially opened yesterday in Ang Mo Kio, offering home care services to an additional 270 elderly people. "We are on track to meeting our target to be able to serve 10,000 seniors by 2020," said Dr Amy Khor, Senior Minister of State for health, at the opening.

Thoughts:
  1. While bringing children to the courts to maintain/ financially support their parents is used as a last resort, the usage of this law also meant that our social fabric is no longer as strong and requires the state's intervention. This might be alarming as it should be a natural deed for children to help take care of their parents, right? 
Thoughts anyone?

Yours,
Something Small Thinking Big

Wednesday, January 6, 2016

Domestic issues? Families can turn to new centre

This post came out from The Straits Times (26 November 2015)

More help is on the way for families at the Family Therapy Institute (FTI), a centre focused on nipping domestic issues in the bud. Aside from marital counselling, specific goal, more open-ended therapy could help couples better address their issues.

A space for the institute, which serves people of all races and religions, was carved out of PPIS' premises, with the cosy chairs and warm earth tones of the decor designed to make clients feel at home. FTI has seen more than 200 cases since starting in April this year.

Besides couples facing marital problems, the institute's four full time therapists have also aided parents who need help managing their children, and working adults.

Also launched yesterday was the Temasek Cares - PPIS Family and Marriage Counselling Programme, which will provide comprehensive marriage counselling services to Malay/Muslim couples.


Thoughts:
  1. It is always nice to see VWOs providing services for all races. Marital problems happens to all races and I think the expertise can be used for benefit for all couples going through this tough period. 
Thoughts anyone?

Yours,
Something Small Thinking Big

Sunday, January 3, 2016

Medifund disbursed $160m for needy in FY2014

This post came out from The Straits Times (26 November 2015)

Close to $160 million was given out through Medifund to help needy patients in the last financial yest, a 23 per cent increase on the previous one. About a third of the money, $52.4 million, went to people aged 65 and older.

Overall, there was a 30 per cent increase in Medifund use, such as for hospital admissions, outpatient clinic visits, and stays in long term care facilities, including nursing homes.

The Ministry of Health (MOH) said the higher amount of assistance in FY2014 comes from extending Medifund and Medifund Silver (reserved for Singaporeans aged 65 years and older) to more healthcare facilities.

Medifund is a social safety net set by the Government in 1993 to help poorer Singaporeans pay for medical treatment - specifically those unable to pay their bills, even after subsidies, insurance, Medisave and cash payments.

They can apply for Medifund aid in public and charitable hospitals at public specialist clinics and polyclinics, at nursing and aged homes, and hospices. For FY 2014 which ended in March this year, 92 per cent of recipients received the full amount applied for.

Patients in C-class wards received the highest amount, averaging $1,750. The close to 900,000 visits to outpatient clinics saw patients receive an average of $95 each. Medifund can also be used for dental care, antenatal care and delivery of babies.

The money comes from income earned from the capital sum of $2.78 billion in Medifund and $1.22 billion in Medifund silver. This is distributed to the 43 Medifund Committees that oversee the distribution of funds to patients of 108 institutions.

The MOH said the Government is "committed to ensure that Singaporeans have access to good and affordable healthcare".


Thoughts:
  1. Is there a high level of awareness of Medifund? Or does Medifund has coverage that do not fill the gap? Why do we hear about people talk about healthcare costs are becoming affordable and do not want to seek help for it? 
Thoughts anyone?

Yours,
Something Small Thinking Big

Saturday, January 2, 2016

New Minds facility to offer caregivers relief

This post came out from The Straits Times (19 September 2015)

Caring for his intellectually disabled son and a mother with dementia was so stressful for Mr Liew Chong Pow that he suffered heart problems while his wife was left on the brink of a nervous breakdown.

Five years ago, their then 26 year old son Jonathan had to return home to be looked after full time after he began beating up his peers at a sheltered workshop. This arrangement was especially trying because he hoarded things, had an obsession with the telephone and used a chair to bang on the door every night.

To give more support to caregivers like Mr Liew, the Movement for the Intellectually Disabled of Singapore (Minds) yesterday opened a new facility in Jalan Ubi. The two storey building at the Kembangang - Chai Chee Community Hub will house a dedicated Caregivers Support Services Centre and Minds largest day activity centre.

Parents and relatives can use the centre's respite care services if they need a break. Counselling, support group sessions and referral services are also provided.

The new day activity centre, which equips those with intellectual disabilities with daily living skills such as personal grooming and hygiene, can take up to 100 clients.

While Minds already has four day activity centres, the waiting list for a place can stretch up to two years.


Thoughts:
  1. I like that we are building up more facilities to support people with disabilities and their family members. More often than not, caregivers experience a lot of stress that they do not readily share with others, and do not know where to seek help from. With more of such centres coming up, I do think that the awareness of such services will increase, and directly helping such families. 

Yours,
Something Small Thinking Big