This post came out from The Straits Times (29 November 2016)
Growing up in a violent household can have the same emotional
impact on a child as a car crash or a natural disaster. In fact, social workers
from the Centre for Promoting Alternatives to Violence (Pave) found that
children who had witnessed abuse - even though they were not hurt - showed
symptoms of trauma.
"Some had flashbacks and nightmares or were
triggered by reminders of the incident," said Ms Monica Zhang, a senior
social worker who spoke on the topic at a Pave seminar last week. "A car
accident is a one-off event but violence at home could be chronic and children
could experience even higher traumatic stress symptoms." She and her team
did a study on 102 children, aged between three and 18, who had received
trauma- focused therapy over the past two years. Half of this group had seen
others being abused and had also been on the receiving end.
The bulk of the others had only witnessed violence
but were traumatised enough to require therapy. Not many people realise that
this group of "invisible children" need as much help as those who
have been abused, said Ms Zhang. "Parents may not think that their
children are affected, but children who are exposed to violence tend to have
more depressive symptoms and score higher on the post- traumatic stress
disorder scale."
While children in these circumstances may not be at
immediate risk of harm, the abuse they witness may leave long-lasting scars. Apart
from depression, some of them develop problematic behaviours like aggression.
They may learn to see violence as a solution to problems and grow up to
perpetrate violence on their own children.
Last year, the Ministry of Social and Family
Development handled 551 child abuse cases, up from 381 in 2014. These included
both physical and sexual abuse, as well as instances of neglect. The ministry
launched a campaign this month to raise awareness of family violence and get
people to flag such cases. Anyone who suspects that an individual is being
abused should come forward.
Abuse cases involving spouses and younger children below 16 form
the bulk of Pave's clients. Senior social worker Angeline Voon said that the
centre has also seen 21 cases of violence towards an older child - 16 years and
above - in the past two years. She added that it is mainly fathers who abuse
their daughters, often to assert authority over them. Ms Voon said: "When
their position is threatened, parents may respond by trying to reassert their
authority."
At last week's seminar, the Ministry of Social and Family
Develop- ment's senior principal clinical and forensic psychologist Chu Chi
Meng shared some of his observations on child abuse in Singapore. For example,
in one study of 440 cases, abuse generally tended to recur frequently in
families where parenting methods involved excessive discipline. And when there
is a child with medical needs, abuse tended to recur more often in large
households with several children, rather than smaller ones. Dr Chu said:
"It makes sense because a child with medical needs in a large household
means an extra burden on the family."
Similarly, another study of 1,750 resolved abuse
cases showed that children from larger families, as well as those who had
unemployed mothers or a low household income, were more likely to be abused
again, even though the problem had seemingly been rectified. This data gives
experts an idea of the dynamics within families, said Dr Chu, adding:
"These could be the points at which to intervene more effectively." Still,
children from abusive backgrounds are not necessarily doomed to perpetuate the
cycle of abuse when they grow older. Ms Zhang said: "There are children
who have experienced violence but don't turn out negative. They had supportive
figures in their lives who were able to set healthy role models."
Thoughts anyone?
Yours,
Something Small Thinking Big