Sunday, July 12, 2015

Mendaki Research Report - Living on a tight budget in Singapore (A qualitative study of 25 Malay/Muslim low-income households)

I recently chanced upon this research report by Mendaki and will like to share some of the key information in it.

Executive summary -

  • The purpose of this research paper is to shed light in the lives of low-income Malay Muslim households in Singapore, in order to understand their vulnerability to shocks, their daily challenges and needs, as well as their aspirations and perceptions about the future. The research team interviewed 25 such households over the course of 15 months, in three rounds of in-depth interviews including a detailed household survey. 
  • Using both open-ended and closed-ended questions, we were able to triangulate qualitative and quantitative data to increase the reliability of our findings and obtain deeper insights unattainable through large-scale survey questionnaires. The richness of the narratives gathered as part of this research highlights the best and worst moments in the lives of these households, and consequently, demonstrates the complexity in addressing their diverse needs. 
  • From a policy perspective, the research aims to provide evidence on how to improve support and services offered to low-income Malay Muslim households, and initiate new ways to address their needs.


Objectives -

  1. To attain in-depth understanding of the households’ everyday lifestyle
  2. Identify the extent to which low-income households are aware of, and benefited from, the presently available assistance schemes within the social service sector
  3. Understand the coping mechanisms and resilience from low-income households, when faced with multiple difficulties.

Key findings -

  1. Most respondents felt ill equipped to help their children in their homework. This was often due to the rigor of the educational system and the lack of familiarity with the curriculum, which differed significantly from the curriculum from the previous generation. 
  2. As part of coping mechanisms, many households in our sample could not afford proper nutrition, and stated that the cost of education put them under financial strain. 
  3. The most important concern for Malay Muslim low-income households is related to health, which illustrates the high level of vulnerability of low-income households to health crises, leading to potential lack of income. Second, lack of stable employment surfaces as another important vicious cycle. Third, stress related to raising children and the difficulties in supporting children in their education.
  4. The level of awareness about available support is low for households with weaker social ties, thereby increasing their vulnerability, and there is a relatively poor knowledge on the extent of support available in Singapore. 
  5. The reasons provided for not seeking assistance vary greatly, from a lack of awareness, a sense of pride, to a strong sense of personal responsibility. 
  6. In general, parents are optimistic about their children’s future financial stability, and no one perceived it as potentially worse. 
  7. Wishes for the Singapore Community include fairness across ethnic groups and looking out more for one another, alluding to an increasingly individualistic society. 
  8. Many respondents regret not studying further in their youth. 
  9. Identifying and removing the fundamental bottlenecks that prevent low-income households from moving upwards socio-economically is a long-term process, because it involves fundamental institutional and social changes. This requires an in-depth re-examination of current strategies (and activities) and their underlying assumptions, and demand open and empathetic leadership at all levels. 
  10. Life priorities and aspirations must be acknowledged and understood further, such that support (to reach these aspirations) can be aligned accordingly, and be demand driven. Indeed, different aspirations lead to different needs, and require an adaptive institutional approach.
  11. The results of this study call for a more individualized approach to addressing needs, according to age, and education background of the parents and primary care takers (including grandparents) and complementary assistance required by the school going children. 
  12. In terms of facilitating access to support, improving awareness and outreach would require proactivity and advocacy. The research findings suggest not just a need to refine targeted support services but also to raise awareness about social assistance. 
  13. For many, their daily pressures are compounded by a significant degree of isolation, that easily becomes a vicious cycle of poverty and ultimately, neglect. 
  14. Finally, there is undoubtedly a lack of voice for many low-income households, especially those headed by elderly individuals and having major responsibilities such as taking care of grandchildren, sometimes referred to as the ‘skip generation’ households.

Conclusions -

For most low-income households in this study, health shocks and loss of income deepens their vulnerability, and at times lead to serious deprivation, including nutritional deprivation. Therefore, beyond showcasing successes and providing role models, there is a need to break vicious cycles and reinforce virtuous cycle. Finally, in order to improve resilience and strengthen coping mechanisms, attention should be paid to closely monitor coping mechanisms and to study the role of social capital in supporting low income households, as these dynamics change very rapidly.


  1. Children and Education 
    • Education is one of the key activities for MENDAKI. Despite the importance given to children’s education by all households in this study, we find that lack of income is only one of the many constraints they faced. Parents and caretakers also mention lack of time, lack of confidence, low self-esteem, as well as lack of familiarity with the curriculum, which compounds their difficulties in providing adequate support to the children under their care. 
    • The results of this study call for a more individualized approach to addressing needs, according to age, and education background of the parents and primary care takers (including grandparents) and complementary assistance required by the school going children. 
    • The findings suggest that MENDAKI could consider engaging further in the following: 
      • A holistic approach to supporting children’s education by targeting groups of parents and caretakers to provide them with skills, knowledge and self-confidence necessary to enable them to support their children’s education. This would complement the direct support provided to the school-going children in many of the existing programs and would also empower parents and caretakers.
      • Major advocacy and awareness campaigns about the issues faced by low-income households on the challenges they encounter in supporting their children’s education. Conduct research specifically on this important topic and bring this evidence at the attention of policy-makers. 
      • Hands-on guidance parents and caretakers on the types of assistance available to them and their children regarding educational support. Take a more individualized approach to support targeted groups such as low-income households headed by elderly taking care of their grand children and households including handicapped children.
    • Various modes support and strategies can be taken by civil society organizations to support low-income households facing difficulties in assisting in their children’s education. A proactive approach would involve working directly with schools and teachers in identifying students that come irregularly to school and who are lagging behind academically. 
    • There is a need for greater role in advocacy, such as providing information on the type of support available to parents and students, and enabling a feedback mechanism or channel for parents and children in difficulty. 
    • Finally, within a broad ranging perspective, is would be appropriate to reappraise institutional strength and weaknesses in the Singapore educational system, to remove some of the main remaining impediments and bottlenecks faced by low-income Malay Muslim households, so that they achieve educational gains at all levels.
  2. Awareness and Perceptions about Social Assistance
    • For social service providers, the findings of this research point towards a need to better understand the systemic bottlenecks faced by low-income households due to the administrative requirements during the application and renewal process. 
    • The results may reveal a need to simplify procedures, provide hands on guidance to the prospective beneficiaries and to invest in staff training, both on a technical and soft skills perspective. In terms of facilitating access to support, improving awareness and outreach would require proactivity and advocacy. 
    • The research findings suggest not just a need to refine targeted support services but also to raise awareness about social assistance, such as in the following ways: 
      • Conduct door-to-door campaigns to raise awareness and provide information on support available to low-income households.
      • Providing assistance during the process of requesting for assistance either by providing transportation and/or helping with the paperwork itself. 
      • Proactively sending out widespread information on the types and sources of support available and the application process. Identify appropriate communication channels beyond those currently used. 
      • Accompany first-time households or those facing particular difficulties, assisting staff in handing complex cases in a sensitive manner.
      • Identify and target protection and support to vulnerable and isolated households, including households headed by elderly individuals. Tailoring support for elderly income earners, and grandparents taking care of grand children. 
      • Provide financial management skills and guidance in managing personal budgets.
    • Our findings suggest that, for many, their daily pressures are compounded by a significant degree of isolation, that easily becomes a vicious cycle of poverty and ultimately, neglect. Therefore, it would be important for civil society organisations to give priority over the provision of specialized support (e.g. from psychologists and social workers) with whom low-income households could voice their concerns confidentially.
    • Beyond providing a listening ear, a complementary strategy should look into the development of accessible channels through which low-income households could voice their concerns (either individually or as a group) for advocacy purposes and to help inform the design of targeted services. 
  3. Broader Implications 
    • The broader implications of our findings and the larger scale considerations suggest the need for a revived advocacy role for Malay Muslim organizations. Many issues need to be tackled head on, from an advocacy perspective. 
    • There is undoubtedly a lack of voice for many low-income households, especially those headed by elderly individuals and having major responsibilities such as taking care of grandchildren, sometimes referred to as the ‘skip generation’ households. Based on our findings, ‘skip generation’ households often emerge out of sheer necessity, rather than on a voluntary basis. 
    • Another aspect of this advocacy role is to address the lack of information on the available support, the rights and the processes to obtain support, for households who find themselves unable to make the first step due to the stigma attached with obtaining or asking for support. In sum, an important area to address is to correct mis-perceptions and misinformation associated with applying for and receiving support. 
Thoughts:

  1. One challenge to reach out to this group of people that I felt was missing is the language barrier due to the multi-racial background of the Singapore society. While younger Malay Muslim families might be able to converse in English, the seniors might only be able to share their information in Malay.
  2. That said, there are also few Malay social work practitioners that can help to meet this demand for Malay speakers too. As such, the Government might want to explore how to shift manpower to staff the sector too.
  3. Lastly, reaching out to these low income families might be a challenge in Singapore as there is a shortage of social workers, and the Government also does not want to be seen as being too much a welfare state by promoting social assistance to the families. It might be a tricky balance too, to outreach the Malay Muslim groups only as it might signal that there is something fundamentally wrong among the community. 
Thoughts anyone?

Yours,
Something Small Thinking Big

Saturday, July 4, 2015

Rice and all things nice for the underprivileged

This post came out from The Straits Times (26 June 2015)

Nearly 80 volunteers turned up at Wisma Mendaki yesterday to pack hampers for 600 underprivileged families. The helpers were from St Andrew's Adult Autism Servies Day Activity Centre and the Land Transport Authority.

The hampers, which contain food items such as Milo and cereal as well as a $50 FairPrice voucher, will be distributed this Saturday and next Saturday. They are given as part of Mendaki's annual Project Joy, which usually helps disadvantaged Malay-Muslims.

But this year, 100 families from other races and religions will be included for the first time, in celebration of Singapore's 50th birthday.


Thoughts:
  1. SG50 has spurred quite a number of things island-wide, be it to promote more volunteerism, or to share a common culture and identity. What have you seen so far that helps the disadvantaged families? 
Thoughts anyone?

Yours,
Something Small Thinking Big

Torn between work and childcare

This post came out from The Straits Times (2 July 2015)

The lack of childcare support makes it challenging for single parents to find time to look for or hold down a job. However, without a job, it is hard to afford childcare service as unemployed single parents benefit from fewer subsidies than working single parents.

This catch-22 situation has led researchers behind a Lien Centre for Social Innovation study of single parent families to call for the provision of childcare and student-care subsidies to unemployed single parents.

The study polled 88 single parents, of whom 28 were unemployed. Almost half said their unemployment was due mainly to the inability to find childcare help. Currently, all parents with Singapore citizen children enrolled in childcare centres qualify for a basic subsidy of $300 a month There is also an additional subsidy of up to $440 if the monthly household income does not exceed $7,500, but this is applicable only to mothers and single fathers who work at least 56 hours a month.

Single parents also cannot qualify for subsidies to defray the costs of after-school student care if they are not working. "This is a problematic policy requirement as, without childcare, a single parent may struggle to seek and attend work, yet without employment she cannot secure the subsidies," said Dr Emma Glendining, who led the study.

Even when single parents can balance work with caregiving activities, their finances are still strained. Almost 40 per cent of the 88 respondents said their average monthly expenditure was greater than their monthly income. Excluding those whose spouses died, about two-third of the  remaining 78 respondents did not receive any kind of financial help from their children's other parent.

Dr Glendinning said the criteria for childcare subsidies could be tweaked to allay concerns that they end up as free handouts for unemployed single parents. "Subsidies could be made available to them for a limited period of time - when they go for a course to upgrade their skills, or if they show an action plan on how they are searching for jobs," she said.

Inaccessibility to childcare services not only affects their employment and financial situation, but may also lead to housing problems. About half of the single parents in the study lived with their parents or relatives mostly because they needed childcare help or were unable to buy their own properties.

Such arrangements are unstable when the family home gets overcrowded or when relationships become strained due to the lack of personal space and privacy. As a result, the study found, more than half of the respondents had moved house at least twice. "All this moving around is not good for the child's emotional development or the single parent who needs to re-establish her own support network in a new community," said Dr Glendinning.

The direction of AWWA Family Service Centre, Mr Edwin Yim, said: "Employment, financial issues and housing are all interlinked, and we need to address them, to provide longer term solutions for single parents. Childcare subsidies for single parents will help the children level up with their peers, by giving them access to supervised and structured programmes."


Thoughts:

  1. A chicken and egg thing on childcare subsidies. I feel that unemployed single parents should be given subsidies as long as they are making effort to look for a job. Perhaps a different tier (lesser assistance, so that they can spurred to get a job and have higher assistance) might be employed if the Government is concerned about the abuse of this system.
Thoughts anyone?

Yours,
Something Small Thinking Big

Those in sheltered work underpaid

This post came out from The Straits Times (2 July 2015)

People with disabilities who are working in sheltered employment are largely underpaid, according to a recent poll by the Lien Centre for Social Innovation. Full time employment in sheltered workshops drew a median monthly pay of $200 to $499.

"It does not even match the industry standard for, say, a cleaner or packer. This is much lower than that," lead researcher Ranjana Raghunathan said."Some respondents liken what they earn at a sheltered workshop to an allowance, rather than a salary, highlighting the meagre pay," she added.

Sheltered employment programmes are run by charities and offer jobs that tend to be low-skilled, such as data entry and telemarketing. The survey polled 100 physically disabled people aged 20 to 59, of whom 46 were in sheltered employment. The rest were in mainstream employment, unemployed or students.

More than half of the 46 said their salaries were low and insufficient to meet their needs, such as living expenses and healthcare costs. Besides proposing higher wages, some respondents also suggested that there be more opportunities to acquire marketable skills while in sheltered employment.

The model of sheltered employment is increasingly unpopular in developed countries. Critics argue that it further isolates people with disabilities, and does not teach skills that prepare them for integration into open employment. But until mainstream employment is more inclusive, it may be important to still have sheltered workshops, said Ms Raghunathan.

At SPF, which represents people with disabilities, some clients who have limited functional abilities earn up to $690 a month, including transport subsidies. But craftsman, who are more skilled and make products such as photo frames by hand, can earn an average of $1,300 a month, including transport subsidies.

SPD executive director Abhimanyau Pal said: "The challenge is in securing enough contract work, and work that pays us better. We hope organizations will be more forthcoming in engaging services offered by our sheltered workshop. Only with more contract jobs or work that brings in higher revenue, are we then able to offer more allowance for the clients."


Thoughts:

  1. I think sheltered workshops are here to stay as I feel that they not only helps those lowly educated and lowly skilled disabled workers to have something meaningful to do in life for some earnings, but also to have their social needs catered for as friendships can be forged in such a setting.
  2. That said, we should not be happy with maintaining status quo. These organizations should find means to upgrade, or discover talents from each of these individuals, such that they can excel and shine in this domain, setting positive examples and role models to showcase that people with disabilities can be equally good as well! 
Thoughts anyone?

Yours,
Something Small Thinking Big

Activities and friends keep seniors happy - up to a point

This post came out from The Straits Times (2 July 2015)

Get grandpa out of the house to mingle with others and he will be less likely to have dementia or be depressed, past research has found. Yet, a new study has discovered that the relationship between social isolation and one's mental well-being is not so clear-cut.

Findings from a study by the Lien Centre for Social Innovation show that while it is generally true that socially active person tends to be less depressed and have higher life satisfaction, that relationship applies only up to a certain amount of social interaction.

Beyond that point, further strengthening one's social network will make no significant difference on his mental well being. "This suggests that once people have a certain level of social interaction, more interaction does not do them much good or harm," said Associate Professor John Donaldson.

Once a person has an adequate social life, his well-being is then more dependent on a myriad of other factors, such as mobility and financial constraints, said the researchers. "This does not mean that a person should stop going out or that there's no point in organizing social activities, but rather we need to address other factors and examine the type of social networks one is in," said Ms Cate Smith, who is one of the study's researchers.

Only certain types of social networks have a big impact on mental wellness, the study found. These are relationships with one's children or grandchildren or people that one can depend on in times of need. Conversely, one's relationship with relatives, friends and neighbors or whether one is living alone or not does not matter as much in determining a person's degree of mental wellness.

"So the implication then is not only to look at the numbers of activities or relationships, but also to enhance the depth of those relationships, especially with family, and one way to do so is to have spaces and services where grandparents and their grandchildren can interact more," said Ms Smith.

Mr Keith Lee, director of AWWA Health and Senior are, said these findings are useful because community groups often see the same few faces on the ground. According to the findings, these activities are unlikely to benefit the regulars much, compared with their potential impact on new people.

"Grassroots or community groups often report that they see a certain number of participants, but actually they are drawing from a common pool of seniors and the beneficiaries can be from the same group of elderly What will be useful is either tracking the number of new participants or getting the regulars to bring in new friends," said Mr Lee.


Thoughts:

  1. This is insightful! I am agreeable that more visitations made by volunteers to a single elderly might not be impactful if the quality of the relationship is not deep enough. How can these volunteers build lasting, deep and meaningful relationship and support for the seniors is something that we should focus on. 
Thoughts anyone?

Yours,
Something Small Thinking Big

Sunday, June 28, 2015

NTUC teams up with mosques to help low income workers

This post came out from The Straits Times (24 June 2015)

Mosques will play a key role in the NTUC U Care Centre's (UCC) push to inform low income workers in the Malay/Muslim community about employment rights and training opportunities. The centre will team up with Singapore mosques to customise programmes and hold workshops for these workers.

UCC director Zanial Sapari said Malay/Muslim workers form fewer than 10 per cent of participants at employment seminars and roadshows. "So we've decided to take a more targeted approach by going to places where there will be many of them", he said. The centre, he added, aims to reach out to 10,000 low wage workers in the Malay/Muslim community this year.

Programmes on the cards include talks at mosques on issue like employment rights, and training youth volunteers and those in the Mosque Befrienders Scheme to explain these issues when they visit low wage workers.

Thoughts:

  1. It is interesting to note that how the unions are reaching out via the mosques to engage a critical mass of a particular community. I think this is an innovative approach, and shows how the religious and secular parties can work together to benefit the community. 
Thoughts anyone?

Yours,
Something Small Thinking Big

Friday, June 26, 2015

Needy residents get free eye checks

This post came out from The Straits Times (22 June 2015)

More than 140 low income residents of Bukit Batok East enjoyed a free eye screening yesterday. The seven-hour mass screening event was organized by the area's grassroots organisations and the Singapore Optometric Association (SOA), together with students from Ngee Ann Polytechnic and Singapore Polytechnic.

Throughout the event, residents received free prescription spectacles that were donated by industry sponsors. About one in five of the residents was also referred for further medical check-ups for conditions that included cataracts and glaucoma.

Jurong GRC MP and Speaker of Parliament Halimah Yacob, who visited the event, said: "Our society is ageing so rapidly, and vision problems are very much associated with age. For the elderly, sometimes the eyes are the most neglected part of the body... But the problem gradually gets worse, complication (develop) and they can become blind. Once they lose their sight, it becomes so sad because then it affects their mobility."

Thoughts:
  1. When people think about caring about needy people, how high is the priority on the care for health and eyes? 
Thoughts anyone?

Yours,
Something Small Thinking Big